Tuesday, August 19, 2008

Rosenstein's JANA Partners Shows New Stakes in Century Aluminum (CENX) and Thinkorswim (SWIM), Boosts AK Steel (AKS) Stake

Barry Rosenstein's JANA Partners released its 13F for the quarter ended June 30, 2008 the other day. Below are some notable moves:

- New 1,204,656 share stake in Century Aluminum (Nasdaq: CENX)

- New 1,012,800 shares stake in Genentech (NYSE: DNA)

- New 8,714,300 share stake in Talisman Energy (NYSE: TLM)

- New 2,344,493 share stake in Thinkorswim Group (Nasdaq: SWIM)

- Raised stake in AK Steel (NYSE: AKS) from 806,261 shares to 4,132,661 shares

- Raised stake in Commercial Metals (NYSE: CMC) from 2,890,314 shares to 4,511,248 shares

- Sold their entire 2,086,000 share stake in Wyeth (NYSE: WYE)

JANA Partners LLC is New York based hedge fund with about $8 billion in assets. The fund launched in April 2001 and is managed by founder Barry Rosenstein. The company primarily invests in the United States public equity markets and uses activist strategies, a market neutral strategy, a long/short equity strategy, and a risk arbitrage strategy while making investments.

Labels: ,

Monday, January 07, 2008

JANA-Led Investor Group Seeks CNET (CENT) Board Takeover

CNET Networks (Nasdaq: CNET) is fractionally higher this morning, following news that an invetor group, led by hedge fund JANA Partners, nominate seven people for election to the company's Board of Directors.

JANA and its partners currently beneficially own approximately 8% of CNET's voting stock and JANA has an additional approximately 8% non-voting economic interest in CNET.

JANA has collaborated with Paul Gardi of Alex Interactive Media and venture capital firm Spark Capital. JANA also said hedge fund Sandell Asset Management, which owns a 5% non-voting interest, has agreed to support its effort.

JANA Managing Partner Barry Rosenstein said, "This effort is about taking an underperforming company and increasing shareholder value by building on its top-notch editorial talent and premier internet assets. Together with Paul Gardi and Spark Capital, we have assembled a group of nominees we believe has the technical skills and business experience to reverse CNET's ongoing underperformance and start delivering value for shareholders."

In response to the announcement, CNet said they have reviewed JANA Partners' proposal and determined that it is improper under the Company's by-laws.

Labels: , , ,

Monday, December 17, 2007

Jana Partners Boosts Copart (CPRT) Stake Above 5%, Files 13D

In a 13D filing on Copart Inc. (Nasdaq: CPRT), Jana Partners disclosed a 5% stake (4,490,540 share) in the company. Jana held 4,469,733 shares at the quarter ended Sept 30, 2007. A 13D indicates a potential 'activist investment'.

In a pretty standard disclosure, the firm did not make any direct requests on the company, but said they will monitor their investment and may enter discussions with management, the Board of Directors or others.

Labels: , ,

Monday, December 10, 2007

Philips (PHG) Shares Up Today After Two Strong Activists Join Forces

JANA Partners and the D.E. Shaw both own Koninklijke Philips Electronics (NYSE: PHG). Over the weekend, these activist investors say they intend to act together to communicate their views, regarding Philips' operating performance and capital structure. The investors hold interests representing approximately 1.6% of the outstanding common shares. No 13D has been filed because the investors do not own 5%.

They filed this disclosure over the weekend, because they did not want to be in violation of Dutch law.

Philips is trading up over 4% today on the news.

Philips Electronics makes a wide range of products from shavers and televisions to medical scanners and light-emitting diodes, in September launched its "Vision 2010" strategic plan.

Labels: , ,

Wednesday, August 22, 2007

New Trades From Top Activists

Here are a few intereting new trades put on from some of our favorite activist funds as disclosed in their lastest 13F filings (Qtr Ended 06/30/07). The stakes mentioned below are all under 5% so no 13Ds are required and the stakes are not nessecarly 'active', but we thought were interesting.

Williamn Ackman's Pershing Square Capital noted a new 10.3 million share stake in office product retailer Staples Inc. (Nasdaq: SPLS).
Jana Partners noted a new 6.5 million share stake in cable company Charter Communications Inc. (Nasdaq: CHTR), a new 725K share stake in broker Goldman Sachs (NYSE: GS), and a new 3 million share stake in rail service company Trinity Industries Inc. (NYSE: TRN).
Robert Chapman's Chapman Capital disclosed a a 460K shares stake in market research firm Harris Interactive Inc. (Nasdaq: HPOL).
Dan Loeb's ThirdPoint disclosed a new 9.65 million share stake in business software company BEA Systems Inc. (Nasdaq: BEAS), a 2.75 million share stake in REIT Douglas Emmett Inc (NYSE: DEI), and a 1.4 million in Veeco Instruments Inc. (Nasdaq: VECO). A full summary of Loeb's 13F is here.
Carl Icahn's Icahn Management's disclosed a new 2.4 million share stake in department store operator Macy's, Inc. (NYSE: M), a 3.5 million share stake in aluminum company Alcoa (NYSE: AA) and a 3.9 million share stake in packaged foods maker Kraft Foods Inc. (NYSE: KFT). A full summary of Icahn's 13F is here.
MMI Investments disclosed a small 138,300 share stake in utility National Fuel Gas Co. (NYSE: NFG)
Warren Lichtenstein's Steel Partners II disclosed a new 2 million share stake in home improvement retailer Home Depot (NYSE: HD), a 642K share stake in adult entertainment company Playboy Enterprises Inc. (NYSE: PLA), a 4.4 million share stake in oil driller Pride International Inc. (NYSE: PDE)
Atticus Capital disclosed a new 1.6 million share stake in heavy equipment maker Caterpillar Inc. (NYSE: CAT), a 2.1 million share stake in electric utililty Entergy Corp. (NYSE: ETR), and a new 4.6 million share stake in oil driller Transocean Inc. (NYSE: RIG).

Labels: , , , , , , ,

Tuesday, June 05, 2007

Hedge Funds JANA and SAC Suggest TD AMERITRADE (AMTD) Should Merge With E*Trade or Charles Schwab

TD AMERITRADE (NASDAQ: AMTD) disclosed that hedge funds Jana Partners and SAC Capital delivered a letter to the board of directors indicating they wish to see TD AMERITRADE pursue a business combination with one of its industry peers, E*Trade Financial (Nasdaq: ETFC) or Charles Schwab (Nasdaq: SCHW). The funds believe that TD Ameritrade can dramatically increase long-term shareholder value through a combination.

The funds believe that representatives of The Toronto-Dominion Bank on TD Ameritrade's Board of Directors may be standing in the way of a merger. The funds suggests to remedy this situation the Board create a special committee, without interference by the directors selected by Toronto-Dominion, to oversee the immediate pursuit of a strategic combination.
The funds believe potential cost and revenue synergies of a combination are enormous. The firms sees total synergies from a Charles Schwab combination of between $800 million to $1 billion in the medium-term. The firms see annual cost savings of $450-$500 million from a strategic combination with E*Trade and estimates that annual revenue synergies from such a combination could exceed $100 million.
The fund have an aggregate "economic interest" in approximately 50 million shares (8.4%) of TD AMERITRADE and notified TD AMERITRADE that each of them has sought regulatory approval to acquire additional shares in excess of $600 million.
A Copy of the Letter:

Gentlemen,
Funds managed by JANA Partners LLC and by S.A.C. Capital Advisors, LLC, respectively, have an aggregate economic interest in approximately 50 million shares of TD Ameritrade Holding Corporation (“TD Ameritrade” or the “Company”), equivalent to 8.4% of the outstanding shares. As we assume you are aware, a fund managed by JANA and a fund managed by SAC have each filed requests for permission under the antitrust laws to substantially increase their respective direct ownership positions. You also may be aware that we have spoken to Company representatives, including W. Edmund Clark.
Based on our due diligence, we believe that TD Ameritrade can dramatically increase long-term shareholder value through a combination with E*Trade Financial (“E*Trade”) or Charles Schwab (“Schwab”). However, we believe that representatives of The Toronto-Dominion Bank (“Toronto-Dominion”) on TD Ameritrade’s Board of Directors (the “Board”), despite glaring and untenable conflicts of interest, may be standing in the way of this result for shareholders. The conflicts arise primarily from the disconnect between the interests of Toronto-Dominion, which views its significant ownership and influence on the Company as being critical to its U.S. strategy and necessary to maintain favorable accounting treatment, and the best interests of the majority of shareholders, who seek maximum value for their shares.
We believe that the only way to remedy this situation is for the Board to create a special committee, without interference by the directors selected by Toronto-Dominion, to oversee the immediate pursuit of a strategic combination. While Toronto-Dominion, as a 40% shareholder, will of course have a large say in whether any strategic transaction ultimately recommended by the Board will be approved, we believe its concerns should not be a gating item when considering strategic alternatives because a majority of shareholders would, we believe, approve such a combination even over Toronto-Dominion’s objections if given the opportunity. On the other hand, if Toronto-Dominion wishes to insist on dictating strategy for the Company based on its own needs, it has the option to make a bid for the remaining equity and pay shareholders full and fair value. In such event, a legitimate sale process would also facilitate the special committee’s determination of fair value.
The most basic fiduciary duties of loyalty and good faith dictate that Toronto-Dominion’s Board representatives not use their Board seats to advance Toronto-Dominion’s interests, and recuse themselves from matters in which the interests of TD Ameritrade’s shareholders conflict with those of Toronto-Dominion. The risks of such conflicts involving Toronto-Dominion are even acknowledged in the Company’s annual report to shareholders. Moreover, such potential conflicts undoubtedly prompted the requirement in the agreement among the Company’s largest shareholders requiring a committee independent of Toronto-Dominion to consider certain matters in which Toronto-Dominion is interested. We would therefore expect each member of the Board to have a heightened sensitivity to such conflicts and make every effort to ensure that Toronto-Dominion’s interests are not given disproportionate weight over the interests of the remaining majority of TD Ameritrade shareholders.
We believe, however, that Mr. Clark and perhaps other Toronto-Dominion Board representatives have impeded the possibility of potential strategic transactions by erasing the lines between their roles as representatives of Toronto-Dominion and directors of TD Ameritrade, putting Toronto-Dominion’s strategic desires in such a transaction above their duty to obtain the best result for all of TD Ameritrade’s shareholders. While Toronto-Dominion may desire to maintain outsized ownership and board representation in any combined entity, terms which are completely unrelated to maximizing value for TD Ameritrade shareholders, the Board’s fiduciary obligations are owed to all shareholders. Despite Mr. Clark’s assertions that the interests of Toronto-Dominion and the Company’s shareholders are aligned, we believe that Toronto-Dominion’s wish to condition any combination on furthering its own strategic benefit clearly belies this claim. Therefore, we believe that allowing Toronto-Dominion’s representatives to influence discussions or negotiations regarding possible strategic transactions, absent clear safeguards to ensure that Toronto-Dominion’s interests do not deprive all other shareholders of maximum value, would represent a clear breach of fiduciary duty.
As set forth below, the benefits which stand to be gained from a strategic combination with Schwab or E*Trade include cost and revenue synergies, strategic benefits and the opportunity to take advantage of industry dynamics favoring consolidation.
Cost Savings and Revenue Synergies. The potential cost and revenue synergies of such a combination are enormous, and are even more compelling given that a combined entity would retain most of the existing revenues of each party. Taking Schwab, for example, we believe substantial cost synergies would be realized by rationalizing overlapping branch networks, meaningfully reducing compensation expense, consolidating back office functions such as call centers, reducing advertising spending and eliminating the recently announced investments in growth. The potential revenue synergies are also highly compelling given the opportunity to increase TD Ameritrade’s share of investable customer assets from approximately 15% to Schwab’s 40-50% level, much higher than the Company could hope to achieve organically given its significantly narrower product set and inferior ability to offer investment advice. We believe that the total synergies from this combination could amount to $800 million to $1 billion in the medium-term, dwarfing the one-time investment required to integrate the two companies’ platforms.
A strategic combination with E*Trade offers similarly compelling benefits. We estimate annual cost savings of $450-$500 million from combining assets onto one platform and cutting duplicative costs, far in excess of the potential upfront cost of integrating E*Trade’s international and multi-currency functionality as well as cross-selling capabilities should TD Ameritrade’s platform be selected. We also estimate that the annual revenue synergies from such a combination exceed $100 million given the opportunity to internalize trades through E*Trade’s in-house market maker, cross-sell E*’Trade’s offerings including cash products to accumulate greater wallet share of customer assets and potentially optimize TD Ameritrade’s balance sheet. While Mr. Clark has communicated to us that the Board is unanimous in its opposition to a combination with E*Trade, given investor and analyst views of the benefits of such a transaction we can only conclude that Toronto-Dominion’s self-serving strategic views have distorted the Board’s analysis.
Strategic Benefits. There are also compelling strategic rationales for such a combination. A combination with Schwab, for example, could offer tremendous potential strategic benefits. While TD Ameritrade has long sought to expand its presence in the core mass affluent long-term investor market, as did TD Waterhouse and Ameritrade separately prior to their combination, its modest track record of organic growth in qualified accounts and assets, narrow product set and unproven ability to offer investment advice gives little indication that it will be successful in doing so. A strategic combination with Schwab, which dominates this market, would solve this problem immediately and provide growth well in excess of that which could possibly be achieved by TD Ameritrade alone, as even Mr. Clark has acknowledged to JANA.
Likewise, combining with E*Trade would provide greater customer lifetime value given the younger average age of E*Trade’s customers and the option to enter international markets, while also allowing TD Ameritrade to obtain a greater share of its customers’ assets and liabilities through E*Trade’s bank. Moreover, while E*Trade has historically traded at lower multiples than TD Ameritrade, we believe that such a combination would not have a negative multiple impact. The multiples placed on TD Ameritrade’s and E*Trade’s earnings have recently begun to converge (factoring out the recent rise in the Company’s stock price attributable to our purchases and takeover speculation) because the percentage of TD Ameritrade’s earnings derived from interest rate spreads or assets now largely equals that of E*Trade and because E*Trade assumes only modest credit risk while presenting the opportunity to offset any multiple discount with greater risk adjusted spreads and thus higher earnings as internally manufactured assets grow.
Industry Dynamics Favoring Consolidation. Consolidation has historically created tremendous value in the discount brokerage sector, and we expect this to be even more true in the future given increased competitive pressures. An industry trending towards $0 commissions will favor increased market share, cost-cutting and increased asset-based revenue opportunities. Moreover, TD Ameritrade’s inability to deliver organic growth comparable to the value it has created through acquisitions during an extended bull market underscores the need for a strategic combination. While the current environment enables a strategic combination given the interest level and complementary business models of TD Ameritrade’s competitors, there is no guarantee this will be true in the future. Put another way, the risks of not pursuing a strategic combination and being left out of industry consolidation are too great to ignore. Particularly now that the Company has effectively completed its conversion of TD Waterhouse’s clients to its platform, there is no excuse for further delay.
Simply put, we believe that Mr. Clark and Toronto-Dominion’s other directors are in an untenable position given that Toronto-Dominion’s strategic interests conflict with the best interests of a majority of TD Ameritrade shareholders. We believe the only solution is for these directors to either step aside and let the Board vigorously pursue a strategic combination, or for Toronto-Dominion to purchase the outstanding equity in the Company. Doing neither and continuing to allow Toronto-Dominion’s interests to stand in the way of maximum value would represent a serious breach of fiduciary duty on the part of Toronto-Dominion’s directors for which we would not hesitate to hold each director personally liable, if necessary. Moreover, directors who stand by passively while this occurs are just as culpable as those who may be doing Toronto-Dominion’s bidding.
We believe, therefore, that the Board must rid itself of potential conflicts in this matter by immediately and publicly creating a special independent committee (or acting through the Company’s Outside Independent Directors Committee or Committee of Non-TD Directors) to oversee the pursuit of a strategic combination, free of any onerous or self-serving conditions set by Toronto-Dominion, and issuing a directive prohibiting Mr. Clark and the other Toronto-Dominion directors from participating in these discussions. We believe it is beyond question that if the Board acts solely in the best interest of all of TD Ameritrade’s shareholders, not just Toronto-Dominion, it will ultimately pursue and recommend a strategic combination to shareholders. Should Toronto-Dominion wish to avoid this result, it may either vote against such a transaction and hope that a sufficient number of shareholders do the same, or it can offer to buy out the remaining public shareholders for full and fair value.
While we have sent this letter privately in the hopes of reaching a prompt resolution to this matter, should the Board fail to promptly task a special committee, free of Toronto-Dominion’s influence, with openly pursuing a strategic combination delivering the benefits described above, we will have no alternative but to resort to other steps we consider appropriate, including if necessary speaking out publicly. You may reach Barry Rosenstein at (415) xxx-xxxx or Steven A. Cohen at (203) xxx-xxxx should you wish to discuss this matter further.
Barry Rosenstein
JANA Partners LLC
Managing Partner
Steven A. Cohen
S. A. C. Capital Advisors, LLC
Chief Executive Officer

Labels: , , , , , , , , ,

Tuesday, May 15, 2007

JANA Nudges Alcoa (AA). Possibly Ingersoll-Rand (IR) Too

In its latest 13F filing, for the quarter ended 03/31/07, JANA Partners disclosed a 3.3 million share stake in Alcoa (NYSE: AA). The stake represents about 0.38% of Alcoa's shares outstanding.

Last week, the firm disclosed a letter to Alcoa calling upon Alcoa's Board of Directors to drop its efforts to acquire Alcan Inc. (NYSE: AL) and to instead focus on creating value for shareholders through an exploration of strategic alternatives, including potentially a sale of Alcoa to one or more buyers.
It is also being speculated that JANA had something to do with Ingersoll-Rand's (NYSE: IR) announcement today that it will explore strategic alternatives for its Bobcat and construction-related businesses and will expand its buyback plan to $4 billion, along with accelerating the plan. JANA showed a 6.3 million share, or 2.08% stake, in Ingersoll-Rand in the latest 13F. This is below the 5% threshold that would require a 13D.

Labels: , , , , , ,

Tuesday, May 08, 2007

JANA To Alcoa (AA): Don't Buy - Sell

Alcoa (NYSE: AA) shareholder JANA Partners LLC called upon Alcoa's Board of Directors to drop its efforts to acquire Alcan Inc. (NYSE: AL) and to instead focus on creating value for shareholders through an exploration of strategic alternatives, including potentially a sale of Alcoa to one or more buyers.

In a letter sent today to Alcoa Chairman and CEO Alain J.P. Belda, JANA Managing Partner Barry Rosenstein stated that, "Given Alcoa's long history of failing to generate shareholder value through acquisitions, we believe that its greatest value can be realized through a sale or break-up of the Company."

JANA said it was a "large shareholder" of Alcoa, but did not disclose the exact size of their stake. The firm did not show an Alcoa stake in the latest 13F (Dec 31, 2006).


A Copy of the Letter:

As a large shareholder of Alcoa Corporation ("Alcoa" or the "Company"), we were shocked by yesterday's announcement that the Company will make a hostile offer for Alcan Inc. at a large premium. Given Alcoa's long history of failing to generate shareholder value through acquisitions, we believe that its greatest value can be realized through a sale or break-up of the Company. Furthermore, we believe that most new shareholders have been attracted to the Company's stock for the same reason and not as the result of any confidence in management's skill as acquirers. By the same token, we assume that yesterday's rise in your share price has more to do with speculation that Alcoa is a target than its acquisition plans. In short, we believe Alcoa should immediately cease its ill- advised pursuit of Alcan and begin a review of all strategic alternatives to maximize shareholder value, including a sale of the Company.

Yesterday's announcement demonstrates in our opinion a blatant disregard on the part of Alcoa's Board of Directors (the "Board") for its duty to pursue maximum value for shareholders, particularly given what appears to be a concentrated effort to stymie shareholder input on this matter. We believe that the Board has done its shareholders a disservice by carefully designing its offer so as not to require the approval of Alcoa's shareholders and announcing it only weeks after Alcoa's annual meeting of shareholders, where shareholders could have voiced their displeasure. In fact, we agree with observers who have noted that the proposed acquisition appears designed to ward off the unwanted advances of potential suitors for Alcoa, which we believe runs directly counter to the wishes of your shareholders.

Alcoa's failure to generate value from past acquisitions is painfully clear. For example, the Company's acquisition of Reynolds and Ivex failed to generate returns above the Company's cost of capital, and now the Company is exploring strategic alternatives for the packaging business developed through these acquisitions. Likewise, the Company's soft-alloy extrusion business, which was also built in large part through acquisitions, has grown to generate over $2 billion in annual sales but generates little or no operating income and will also be sold. Most telling, despite these and other large acquisitions, the Company's stock price has been stagnant. From its high point in January 2001, when you assumed the position of Chairman of the Board in addition to the CEO role, through last Friday prior to the announcement, Alcoa's stock price has been essentially flat, despite the occurrence of one of the biggest metals booms in decades during this period. We believe a major transformational acquisition is a particularly inappropriate sign-off to your tenure as Chairman and CEO next year. Moreover, a management team which has failed to generate shareholder value through acquisitions should not be rewarding itself by aggregating more such assets.

We believe management's refusal on yesterday's call to share even the most basic assumptions used to justify the proposed acquisition, such as the projected price of aluminum used to determine whether the transaction would be accretive to earnings, underscores the tenuous reasoning behind pursuing this transaction rather than other strategic alternatives. We are also highly skeptical that Alcoa's underperforming management team can achieve the proposed $1 billion in cost savings from the proposed transaction. Moreover, we find it appalling that, by your own admission on yesterday's call, the Board did not even consider whether more value could be created for shareholders through a break-up of the Company before deciding to pursue Alcan.

For these reasons, we call on the Board to abandon this misguided effort and pursue other strategic alternatives, including potentially a sale of the Company to one or more buyers. We are confident that should the Board insist on pursuing this acquisition rather than pursuing maximum value for its shareholders through all possible means, Alcoa's shareholders will respond forcefully at next year's annual meeting, including if necessary by replacing members of Alcoa's Board of Directors.

Sincerely,

Barry Rosenstein
JANA Partners LLC
Managing Partner

Jared Sturdivant
JANA Partners LLC
Managing Director

Labels: , , , ,